He hopes to fit in with others and keep everyone at peace, though nobody knows he is mentally broken. Chris Sarandon as the Puppet, a puppet/marionette that has a mind of its own.Adam Wylie as Balloon Boy, a humanoid animatronic who is rather energetic and enthusiastic, but sometimes annoying and bothersome.He follows Withered Freddy's footsteps to get rid of the Toy Animatronics, but unintentionally becomes friends with Mangle and Balloon Boy. Jim Cummings as Withered Foxy, Foxy the Pirate Fox from the past, in a state of disrepair.She is a sad, broken down chicken who feels bad for her friends and wishes that they can be fixed. Bebe Neuwirth as Withered Chica, Chica from the past, in a state of disrepair.He is a worn down rabbit who has been through so much, along with making jokes about his face. Michael Richard as Withered Bonnie, Bonnie from the past, in a state of disrepair.He leads his friends in an attempt to get rid of the Toy Animatronics for getting more fame and praise. Edmund Gilbert as Withered Freddy, Freddy from the past, in a state of disrepair.Because of being taken apart by children and left for dead by the employees, she has an extreme prejudice of humans, in which she often interrogates Jeremy. Tress MacNeille as Mangle, a broken down, animatronic fox that was supposedly the new and improved Foxy the Pirate Fox.She is also unaware that Toy Bonnie feels the same way. She hopes to be Toy Bonnie's girlfriend, but is scared to be open with him. Tara Strong as Toy Chica, the classy, beautiful, new and improved Chica the Chicken.He hopes to gain Toy Chica's love, but is scared to admit.
John Kassir as Toy Bonnie, the cool, laid-back, new and improved Bonnie the Bunny.He enjoys reading books and keeping the pizzeria in perfect condition.